Simone Baxter comes to Feinstown to find out the circumstances surrounding the death of her journalist sister. As she navigates the web of mystery that seems to entangle the entire town, Simone suddenly realizes that her only assistant, the grumpy and sarcastic Mike Gasway, is the best man she's ever met. But he has a reason to consider himself useless and therefore hide from life. Now Simone has to find two keys: the key that opens the door to the secret of the small town, and the key with which Mike locked the door to his heart.