In the town of Mission Ridge, Georgia, historical reenactors gather to re-enact a major battle. However, things take a very bad turn: the mock-up weapons suddenly turn out to be deadly, and the quiet fan of the past turns out to be a cold-blooded killer. All the threads point to Confederate Captain Jubal Beauchamp and a relic called the Judas Loop, which became part of a dark curse towards the end of the War Between the States. What at first seemed like a frivolous showdown between demons turned out to be a major game for several games, in which the fates of Dean and Sam became pawns. The events take place during the fifth season of the series.