You'd think that after rescuing your boyfriend from an eternity in Hell, everything would go back to normal. Well, just as normal when we can see souls and our boyfriend Death. But for Pagan Moore, some things are still strange. High School quarterback and heartthrob Leif Montgomery is missing. Although the town is in a state of unrest, Pagan is nervous for other reasons. Apparently good Leif is not an ordinary teenager. He's not even human. After Death, Leif had no soul left. The quarterback may be able to sneak into town, but he still shows up in Pagan's dreams... uninvited. Dank knew from the start that Leif was not human. But he was not bothered by simple soulless creatures. Now he realizes that he made a serious mistake. Pagan's soul was marked as restitution from the very beginning, by such a dark spirit that even Death walks beside it. Dank knew it wouldn't be easy to save Pagan's soul, but Pagan was his. And he would again ignore Heaven to keep her safe. If Hell wants a piece of him, then he will have to share.